Capturing Chaos

Wrestling words and ideas into submission

&
 

Nov 19 2008

426 Unedited Words

Published by catana at 1:26 pm under Uncategorized Edit This

I was in the middle of editing another chunk of the free writing that I wrote about yesterday when I thought it might be interesting to post the original today and the edited version tomorrow. So here, warts and all, is another selection from the top of my head.

“Why do so many people want to be writers when they lack every qualification? They have illusions of adequacy because words are all around us, they’re what we use every day, so it’s assumed that there’s nothing special about them. There’s nothing we need to know about words or language because it’s part of our everyday experience. We think that the grunts of those around us and the grunts we offer then in return are equivalent to what a writer produces and ultimately shows up on the pages of books and magazines.

“It’s a very different thing, though, almost a different world. It is a different world, one you enter either prepared or unprepared. If you’re start out unprepared, and refuse to change your status, you will eventually be cast out, whether rudely or politely, it doesn’t really matter, except in how it affects your understanding. Too polite a rejection teaches nothing. It allows the incompetent to believe that if they just keep trying, the doors will open and they’ll be admitted to the inner sanctum and to what they mistakenly believe is an endless flow of money and adulation.

“If one of these aspiring writers were to take a look at what I’ve produced in the last 15 minutes or so, they would be impressed, possibly awed. How can someone just sit down and produce so many words in such a short time? And where do the ideas come from? They have no conception of what goes into becoming a writer, even one as mediocre in many ways as myself. Years of reading and absorbing the language and its uses. They think that taking courses, being told how to write, how to go about it, are what they need, but it never occurs to them that most writers have never taken a course. The great writers of the past would laugh at such a notion, knowing that their teachers were the writers of previous generations and those of their own generation worthy of their admiration. They might emulate those writers as part of the learning process, but they never took courses or had a teacher in the sense in which we understand teachers.

“So reading is the base, the core of everything that a writer is. Without that base, it’s impossible to become a writer. There is nothing to draw on, nothing learned. The writer who doesn’t read, who hasn’t been reading since early childhood is nothing but an empty shell, and all he can produce is wind the meaningless natter that passes for communication.”

Possibly-related Articles:                                        (auto-generated)

3 Responses to “426 Unedited Words”

  1. zannahjaneon 19 Nov 2008 at 5:08 pm edit this

    I totally agree with you. I wrote a post yesterday about the importance of writer’s taking time to read (www.writingforyourlife.today.com). Also, I agree with your comment about writing courses. I took one year of creative writing at university, but it was totally pathetic. I changed my major to English Lit and have never regretted it.

  2. zannahjaneon 19 Nov 2008 at 5:10 pm edit this

    Sorry, I should set a good example and proofread my comments–that should be ‘writers.’

  3. catanaon 19 Nov 2008 at 5:26 pm edit this

    I’m not totally against writing courses. If the instructor is a successful writer and also knows how to teach and inspire, not just give a set of rules, then I’m sure some people would gain something that they might have trouble with on their own. But getting a degree in writing is no substitute for doing it.

    Shame, shame. LOL I promise not to lower your grade.

Trackback URI | Comments RSS

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.
Not A Member? Register for Free!

Some Today.com contributors may have received a fee or a promotional product or service from a manufacturer for promotional consideration, while others receive no consideration at all. Each contributor is responsible for disclosing any such promotional consideration.